So we got our names and we got our report and at the end of the day (OK, the middle of the afternoon), all we really have is disappointment.
The Mitchell Report, generated by former Senate Majority Leader George Mitchell, was released this afternoon and revealed what we largely already should have known — the steroid culture was (and is, if you count HGH and other performance-enhancing drugs) widespread in Major League Baseball.
For fans of players like Roger Clemens, Andy Pettitte, Eric Gagne, Miguel Tejada and Chuck Knoblauch, it’s the disappointment that players they cheered for allegedly cheated the game. Yankee fans were particularly beaten up with Clemens, Pettitte, Knoblauch, Ron Villone, Denny Neagle, Mike Stanton, David Justice, Rondell White and Kevin Brown all implicated, along with the obvious Jason Giambi and Gary Sheffield revelations. (Geez, did I miss any?) But the Mets were far from unscathed with Todd Hundley, Lenny Dykstra, Mark Carreon, Matt Franco, Paul Lo Duca, Todd Pratt (What’s with the catchers?), Mo Vaughn, Scott Schoeneweis and Stanton. Plenty of blame to go around. Plenty of disappointment too.
But the disappointment associated with the Mitchell Report isn’t isolated to just the fans. There’s also a great deal of disappointment in the burden of proof in this report. I’m on mini-vacation right now, so I’ve only had a few minutes to peruse the report, but there’s some stuff in there that just isn’t solid enough. There’s outright hearsay in there and that’s going to discredit the entire report — most of which is probably dead on accurate. That’s disappointing.
And then there’s the overall picture which is the report is simply not enough. For anything substantial to come of this, the public had to be outraged. There are some big names, but not enough. It had to be bad for it to get better. It’s wasn’t bad enough and that will mean many of Mitchell’s recommendations — valid arguments for bettering the game — likely will not be implemented. All the while, as Mitchell noted, HGH use continues without fear of discipline. And so the Steroid Era continues on…
And that’s the ultimate disappointment.
*****
Bud Selig just indicated in his press conference that he would deal with the idea of disciplining active players on a case-by-case basis. That goes directly against one of Mitchell’s recommendations that players not be punished for past discretions. Apparently he consulted Mark McGwire before making that recommendation. Let’s not talk about the past, right? More likely, Mitchell just understood that the level of proof was not up to snuff on all the names. As long as players aren’t getting suspended for hearsay, Selig is within his rights to dole out some punishment here.
*****
The obvious question on Mets fans’ minds is whether Omar Minaya and the Mets management were so dead-set against re-signing Lo Duca because they suspected he would be part of this report.
They’ll never own up to it, but you have to assume that was at least a consideration. Otherwise why would the Mets have gone to such great lengths to replace him. After all, they effectively brought in three catchers (Yorvit Torrealba, Johnny Estrada, Brian Schneider) over the course of a month, when they could have simply re-signed Lo Duca at any time.
I was critical of their decision from a baseball standpoint and stand by that assertion. However, I will concede that there may have been other factors that we weren’t privy to.