Growing up a sports fan in the Tri-State Area, you quickly learned to find 660 on the AM dial — the home of WFAN, the nation’s first all-sports talk radio station. I remember spending my summer days out in the backyard with the FAN blowing out of my hideously 80s-ish red boombox. There were a lot of Mets games (back when MLB scheduled day games) and some good sports talk that really expanded my sports universe. I remember taping an hourlong interview with Tom Seaver on a cassette tape that I still probably have somewhere. And of course, I remember staying up to 3 a.m. on Saturday nights to listen to Jody MacDonald talk professional wrestling and then trying not to doze off in church the next morning. OK, I probably would’ve had that problem anyway, but the lack of sleep sure didn’t help.
My point is, you don’t really become a big-time sports fan until you’re 10 or 11 and that’s right about when the FAN came into existence. July 1, 1987 to be exact. Without it, I don’t know that I’d be the sports fan I am today or even working in the sports media. So despite the maddening hosts and the over-reactive callers that sometimes plague the station, I know I’d miss WFAN if it were gone.
To help celebrate it 20th anniversary, the FAN ran a promotion where listeners could vote for the Top 20 moments of the last 20 years in New York sports. Here’s the list, as decided by the fans:
20: WFAN’s First Broadcast
19: David Cone Perfect Game
18: Buster Douglas KO’s Mike Tyson
17: Rangers Trade for Mark Messier
16: Endy Chavez Catch
15: Cal Ripken Breaks Gehrig’s Record
14: Clemens v. Piazza
13: Robin Ventura Grand Slam Single
12: Mets Win 2000 NLCS
11: Mets Sign Pedro Martinez
10: Mets Trade For Mike Piazza
9: Jeter Flip to Posada
8: Yankees Win 2000 World Series
7: Aaron Boone 2003 ALCS Home Run
6: Stephane Matteau GW OT Goal
5: Mike Piazza 9/11 Homerun
4: Red Sox End Curse
3: Yankees Win 1996 World Series
2: Norwood Misses FG, Giants Win SB XXV
1: Ranger Win 1994 Stanley Cup
It’s an interesting list, peppered by Mets moments, which is interesting considering the Yankee dominance over most of the last decade. What I think hurts the Yankee dynasty is the World Series wins haven’t been filled with the dramatic moments like the losses have. Think about the clips you see on YES throughout the day: Boone, the D’back late-inning homers and the Jeter flip are far more memorable to the average fan than anything that happened in 1996, 98 or 99. And 2000 was overshadowed by the Piazza-Clemens debacle. So I think that’s how there were six Mets moments and five Yankee moments in the Top 20, not counting the Red Sox ending the curse or the Piazza-Clemens thing.
As for my list, I struggled because I really don’t think you should count moments where the team didn’t ultimately succeed, which eliminates the grand slam single and the Chavez catch — which were amazing moments, but can’t stand up because of their lack of overall meaning. I also find it difficult to judge the national events like Ripken and Tyson because we’re talking New York here and I don’t really see the impact. Regardless, I came up with my Top 5, so let’s hit it.
No. 5: Yankees Win 1996 World Series — Surprised, considering I’m a Mets fan? You shouldn’t be. I say it all the time and most Yankee fans don’t believe me, but I was actually happy when the Yanks returned to the mantle in 96. I knew a lot of Yankee fans at the time and they had suffered through those dreadful teams in the 80s and all the Steinbrenner distractions. So I was glad that those fans were rewarded. If I knew then that it would create the largest bandwagon in the history of sports and years later I’d be accosted by drunken idiots yelling “26 BABY!” in my face in the Shea Stadium men’s room, I might have reconsidered. But at the time it was a major moment in New York, and while it doesn’t have the sizzle of some of those other Yankee highlights, its significance remains.
No. 4: Matteau, Matteau, Matteau — At the time, I was working my first season at Six Flags Great Adventure in Jackson, N.J. As an 18-year-old Games & Attractions cast member, I often stayed late into the night, helping fix up the games area after the onslaught of summer crowds. Given the NHL’s recent ratings woes, it’s easy to forget that the Devils-Rangers Eastern Conference Finals was huge in this area. It was on everyone’s mind that night so someone in an office tuned into the game on the radio and broadcast it throughout the deserted theme park over one of the walkie-talkie channels. I was on a ladder, hanging stuffed pigs and cows on the wall of the “Barnyard Baskets” game when the Devils scored with seven seconds left to send the game into overtime. I was so angry, I lost my balance, falling safely into a pile of plush prizes. We finished up at the end the first overtime and I ended up driving home through the intermission. I didn’t quite make the time I was hoping to and the second overtime started before I got home. As I pulled onto my family’s street in East Windsor, Stephane Matteau scored the game-winner, sending the long suffering Rangers to the Stanley Cup Finals. Just as Howie Rose finished his legendary “Matteau, Matteau, Matteau” call, I started laying on my horn (Hey, no one should have been sleeping during that game.) and ran into my parents’ house just in time to see the replay of the fateful goal. Any moment I remember that vividly belongs in the Top 5.
No. 3: Clemens v. Piazza — I think people are starting to forget how big this thing was. It overshadowed a World Series, even before a shattered bat was ever thrown, and then continued for another two years until Shawn Estes managed to miss Clemens rather significant a$s. As Mike Francesa said on the FAN this afternoon, they could start taking calls on it today and it would still get heated. From a Mets fan perspective, Clemens beaning Piazza was like when Shooter McGavin had some dude run over Happy Gilmore because he couldn’t beat him fair and square. In Hollywood, Happy won anyway. In reality, Piazza had to wait a couple years before getting his happy ending. No, I’m not talking about his home run in the regular season game. I’m talking about when he gave away the pitches to the AL batters while catching Clemens in the All-Star Game. Watching the Rocket get rocked on a national stage — that was the happy ending to this saga.
No. 2: Super Bowl XXV — It remains unquestionably the greatest Super Bowl I’ve ever seen and it doesn’t hurt that the Giants won. But from an actual gameplay standpoint, both these teams were nearly flawless as they slugged it out in a physical war of a football game. Adding to the atmosphere was the actual war taking place in the Gulf which led to the most inspirational lip synching you’ll ever see from Whitney Houston. But the game will always be remembered for Scott Norwood missing the climactic kick and the underdog Giants winning their second Lombardi Trophy.
No. 1: Rangers Win The Cup — Without hesitation, this was the greatest moment of my sports fandom. Fifty-four years of frustration capped off with a tense 60 minutes of hockey. I just remember sitting on the edge of the sofa with my elbows on my knees and looking across the family room at my old man, sitting on the edge of the loveseat with his elbows on his knees. And we waited and waited. I hadn’t even been alive for 19 of the 54 years of frustration at that point, but every Ranger fan carried that burden that night. There was even that damn icing call to force one final faceoff before we could finally celebrate. For drama, for joy, for excitement, this event can never be topped. Every sporting event to come will always be fighting only for No. 2 on this list.
So that’s it. That’s my list. Here are the two events that almost made the cut… but didn’t.
HONORABLE MENTION: Piazza 9/11 Homer — It meant very little from a baseball perspective, being a regular season game in a year the Mets didn’t even make the playoffs. But from a societal standpoint, it was incredibly important. We all walked around in a daze after Sept. 11, unable to comprehend how the attacks could have transpired and unable to distract ourselves as television was overrun with round-the-clock news coverage and the sports world went on hiatus. Piazza homering in the first game back signalled somewhat of a return to normalcy and reminded us that it’s OK to cheer.
HONORABLE MENTION: O.J. Bronco Chase — This will always be one of the watershed moments in the history of television. It was salacious, shocking and celebrity all wrapped into one, transpiring live in the middle of an Knicks-Rockets NBA Finals game. I actually didn’t see it live (Six Flags again) but I had recorded the game on my VCR. I drove home listening to a mix tape, undoubtedly filled with 1994-ish music like Stone Temple Pilots and Jesus & Mary Chain, and avoided the result of the game so I could watch it as if it were live. It was late though, so I just started fast-forwarding through the game when all of sudden I noticed the split screen. “What the hell is that white Bronco doing? And why is it going so slow?” This event was the springboard for the O.J. story, which crossed all sorts of sports and societal boundaries and changed television news forever. Like most people, I still remember the details of the chase. I don’t remember the result of the game.
Wow, this became a ridiculously long post. I guess that’s what happens when my planned Mets game falls through. So anyway, Happy 20th WFAN. Hopefully, there will be some more great New York sports moments happening at Shea this October.