In a surprise ranking right up there with Road Runner outsmarting Wile E. Coyote, a boat sinking at the end of “Titanic,” and Jack Bauer saving another day, Cal Ripken Jr. and Tony Gwynn were elected to the Hall of Fame today.
Ripken garnered the third highest percentage ever for the Hall, despite this trendy growing backlash against the Oriole great. I’ve seen way too much discussion lately questioning just how good Ripken was and everyone couches it as, “well, he’s a Hall of Famer but…” In the mid-1990s, those kind of statements would have gotten you committed, but apparently we’ve become more astute over the last six or seven years. Did I miss these damning revelations against Ripken? Let the guy enjoy his day, he deserves it.
And then there’s Mark McGwire paying for the sins of steroids. For years now I’ve held the same opinion on steroids: I’m not going to get up in arms about it because I truly believe most athletes take something, thus negating the supposed competitive advantage, but a large portion of the country will freak in that “What about the children?” way, so MLB needs to at least give the impression they are cleaning up the sport. MLB, of course, failed miserably at that and continues to pay the price today as now their ridiculous “tests that don’t count” are at the heart of the government-MLB struggle.
But the sport itself isn’t the only casualty here. McGwire’s reputation is as well. Now the slugger did himself no favors with his pathetic performance before Congress, but MLB has failed McGwire as well. When you consider everything McGwire did for the sport in 1998, putting the national back in national pastime, as the country became enamored with his and Sammy Sosa’s pursuit of the elusive home run record, you would think MLB would do a little more to protect their once-golden boy. If for nothing else, it would have benefitted the sport to have McGwire be a viable ambassador, rather than the humbled hermit he has become. But they owed it to McGwire too.
It wouldn’t have taken much for baseball to handle this situation differently and protect its players in the process. Three or four years ago, Bud Selig could have held a press conference admitting that baseball had been slow to recognize the emergence and dangers of performance enhancing drugs, but that the players during the late 1990s were acting within the rules of the game at the time. Now that would have meant that the players association would have had to allow baseball to institute a stringent policy from that point forward and the McGwires of the world would have to talk a little about the past. But can’t we all agree that would be far more pleasant than what we’re left with today?
Because as a result, McGwire got less than 25 percent in voting for the Hall. It will go up in future years as those who were merely keeping him off in his first year will relent. But it’s doubtful he will ever have that bust in Cooperstown. And that’s ridiculous.
But then again, Pete Rose would be in my Hall of Fame too.